The
Real Battle in 'Bama
by
Travis K. McSherley
“What
is of supreme importance in war is to attack the enemy's strategy.” --
The Art of War
Anyone
who believes that the ongoing fiasco at the Alabama Judicial Building is
about a two-ton rock hasn’t been paying enough attention. State supreme
court chief justice Roy Moore’s Ten Commandments monument is merely the
latest battlefield in an ongoing fight over God’s place in United States
society.
It’s
not about the U.S. Constitution. Even the most liberal reading of
the document -- including the First Amendment -- would fail to produce
any real justification for forcing the monument’s removal. No laws
have been enacted in Alabama to force acceptance of a religion, and there
is no legal punishment allotted for those who choose to reject (most) of
the statements on the statue.
It’s
not about the Alabama Constitution, which explicitly acknowledges the existence
of God and his authority. To suggest that Moore has violated the
spirit or letter of his state’s legal foundation would nullify its entire
premise.
It
even goes beyond the “separation of church and state.” Justice Moore
is hardly advocating a theocracy by providing a visible tribute to the
Ten Commandments in his courthouse. American history, from the Declaration
of Independence on, is filled with allusions to God and Scripture even
less subtle than the Decalogue etched in stone in Alabama.
The
Pledge of Allegiance declares “one nation under God.”
The
U.S. national anthem admonishes the citizenry to “praise the Power that
hath made and preserved us a nation.”
U.S.
currency is stamped with the motto, “In God We Trust.”
The
obvious question should be: How does a state’s decision to display the
Ten Commandments constitute more of a federal religious endorsement than
more than two centuries of American acknowledgement of the God of the Bible?
It
is difficult to believe that groups such as the American Civil Liberties
Union and Americans United for the Separation of Church and State truly
believe that they are upholding the U.S. Constitution with lawsuits over
prayer in schools, plaques with Scripture hanging in the Grand Canyon or
monuments depicting the Divine.
Anyone
threatened by Moore’s monument would feel most uncomfortable reading the
words of our Founding Fathers or walking through the government buildings
and memorials in Washington. And though some people would no doubt
claim to be offended by being presented with God’s commands, that’s not
enough to make it illegal to display them.
Yet
the issue isn’t about the Ten Commandments, which have long since been
trampled upon and degraded. We can’t even get past the first one
-- “Thou shalt have no other gods before me.” And lying? Idolatry?
Adultery? Covetousness? Heck, these are the threads by which
American pop culture is weaved. If you don’t believe it, just tune
in to five minutes of the latest reality show (or CNN, for that matter).
Last
year’s 9th Circuit decision to take the Pledge of Allegiance out of public
schools should have been a wake-up call that the very foundations of our
national heritage are on the debate table. The real battle is to
determine the worldview that will form the basis of American culture for
the future.
At
stake are personal freedoms and a set of moral values that have been at
the core of our nation since it was born. It’s no secret that these
are under attack. A redefinition of cultural traditions and values
is being attempted. The battlefields are plentiful within the courts,
in the media, in academia and in the church.
That’s
why the confrontation in Alabama matters. The monument itself is
largely irrelevant, but the tug-of-war over it is reflective of the larger
war over God’s place in our society. Those on the far left merely
want to make sure that it’s their religion that gets to be accepted by
the state. And chipping away the foundations of Judeo-Christian beliefs
is an effective strategy to use, starting with the removal of a pesky reminder
of God’s high standards. |