Dusting
off the Swords:
A Review of The Compleat
Gentleman
Travis K.
McSherley
September
2004
Men are failing.
Healthy marriages are rare, while
collapsed unions have become the norm. Wives often find a famine
of sacrifice or intimacy from the knights they thought they married.
Not to mention the fact that the institution itself has been called into
question by those wanting to change its definition or by those declaring
it a relic of another age. Children are deprived of disciplinarians
and models who will establish firm boundaries and yet offer utmost love.
A nation finds "a few good men" to fight its wars, but what of the smaller
battles back home?
Clearly, not every man carries the
responsibility for a broken culture, but masculinity in general has fallen
into disarray. And the damage is extensive. Not only have men
taken lightly their supreme commitment to family, but many have become
immersed in business and politics to the point that a word and a handshake
too often represent an empty promise, rather than an immovable bond.
In times past, a man was expected
to carry himself as a gentleman, expressing the highest deference to women
and unflinchingly defending what is right and true. But now, we regrettably
see that kind of a man as an anomaly, an outdated antique not needed in
our enlightened days of "equality" and "tolerance."
Political correctness has spurned
the gentleman into a more passive role, lest he be accused of oppression
or machismo. Meanwhile, dishonesty and corruption are stereotypical
of the corporate and political worlds.
Though I wouldn't consider it exhaustive,
the failure runs deep. And the weight of it falls on men, rather
than women, because men have been entrusted -- by God, by tradition, and
in general by law -- to be protectors of justice and beauty at home and
in the world. The movements of feminism and liberalism haven't changed
that, although they have made it more difficult, to be sure. But
men are still called to be men, and boy, does the world need them.
To that end, author Brad Miner offers
The
Compleat Gentleman: The Modern Man's Guide to Chivalry, a book
that traces the history of the gentlemanly ideal through ancient times
to the knights of the Age of Chivalry up to the present-day dearth.
"This is a book about an ideal," writes
Miner, "and the reader will find that a belief in the importance of aspiring
to that ideal is treated here as nothing less than dogma. No man
behaves as a compleat gentleman all the time, but the best men never cease
yearning to."
Part history and part modern application,
The
Compleat Gentleman explores how the gentleman has evolved, and it offers
a charge to men today to reclaim the torch of chivalry. The book
does not, however, idealize the gentlemen of the past as many works are
prone to do. Rather, Miner writes of real men with real imperfections,
but men who knew that honor and love were worth any sacrifice.
"And if one tenet of the contemporary
worldview represents a heretical break with tradition, it is in the confident
assertion that nothing is worth fighting for, which is to say, dying for,"
Miner says. "Implied in this is the assumption that peace is always
preferable to war and life is always preferable to death, and here the
compleat gentleman dissents -- militantly -- even if he himself is not
combat ready."
Indeed, of all the classical views
of manhood, the one we are least comfortable with is that of a warrior.
Yet, that fighting spirit is what really defines a gentleman. It
is not limited to physical struggles (and no gentleman enters a man-to-man
confrontation unless he's forced to), but at the heart of manliness, by
and large, is a deep-seated fervor to conquer evil and to uphold good.
As Miner writes, "The compleat gentleman,
as a warrior, cannot abide injustice, and justice is finally the one and
only thing worth fighting and dying for. Peace is justice in foreign
relations; equality is justice in society; passion is justice in marriage;
wisdom is justice in education; restraint is justice in behavior."
Along with this essence of a soldier
comes -- whether as its supplement, or as its fuel -- what Miner describes
as "the lover" and "the monk." A lover because a gentleman is always
seeking to please and romance his fair maiden; and a monk, because he ever
carries the mantles of integrity and self-control.
Perhaps few men throughout time have
actually achieved this ideal; certainly fewer have achieved their entire
adult lives. But in modern culture, even the ideal has been lost.
We owe it to today's man -- and maybe just as much to today's woman --
to push him to strive toward chivalry. I don't think that's such
a lofty objective.
"The compleat gentleman is merely
a man," Miner writes, "and perhaps we make the process of defining chivalry
too difficult because we lack the faith necessary to grasp its essential
simplicity. In the end, chivalry is nothing more than putting the
self second…in the moments that matter the compleat gentleman makes himself
the servant of his God, his nation, his friends, his family…."
The call of The Compleat Gentleman
is extremely relevant, and the future of the culture demands that men stand
up and bring honor to their God, family, country. As a man myself,
I certainly carry the weight of that burden, and pray for the strength
to shoulder it.
I do think, however, that Miner perhaps
underestimates the role of faith in the life of the gentleman. He
says: "If a gentleman is not per se religious, he is inherently monkish
in that, like his cloistered and professed brethren, he is a man living
under a dispensation of principles…even agnostic and atheist gentlemen
(and there probably aren't many of the latter) are guided by at least one
principle….He believes he ought to do the right thing."
Not that a Christian belief is required
to be a just man, but without the abiding hope of eternal life and the
conviction of a holy God, a man has little solid foundation upon which
to base his pursuit of goodness. After all, Christ is the pre-eminent
gentleman -- the fiercest warrior, the most humble King, and the most caring
lover. Without His example and daily guidance, a man remains doomed
to defeat.
Still, the message rings true -- and
blares like an alarm bell to awaken a largely dormant concept. Women
deserve men who will fight for their beauty, and who would put their very
lives on the line on behalf of their beloved. Children deserve fathers
who will model real manliness, provide security, and teach truth.
And a nation deserves men who will be intolerant toward injustice.
Men who will stand uncompromisingly for their faith and their loved ones.
May the knights ride again. |